I think that is the most dumbest thing I ever heard..lol..I will stick with spanking my children..when they do get a spanking they know it is serious...
I think they just keep trying to find new reasons to restrict parents from doing anything to thier children...mind you there is a difference between spanking and child abuse!! But now you're almost afraid to dicipline your children at all anymore!!
I think I got spanked once when I was younger. I just knew when my dad told me NO, he meant it. My little sister on the other hand... If my dad said don't touch that, she would put her pinky on it lol
What would the difference be?
Open handed spanking of your child on the butt is okay. Beating your child with a belt, closed fist, or any other object falls under child abuse.
I don't know about here but in Texas you can actually have a cop come and witness a proper punishment of your child so that it can not be deemed as child abuse, and taken to CPS.
I don't see anything wrong with open handed smacking on the butt. JMO
Says who?
In Texas a you can have a cop come to your home and witness you spanking your child.
So the law. At least in Texas.
Personally, yes there is a fine line between child abuse and discipline when it comes to corporal punishment. I am not going to say I will never spank my daughter but it will NOT be my first choice. More like the last alternative.
I don't know about here but in Texas you can actually have a cop come and witness a proper punishment of your child so that it can not be deemed as child abuse, and taken to CPS.
if you need a cop to come watch you to justify that you're not abusing your child, you might have an issue... lol
if you need a cop to come watch you to justify that you're not abusing your child, you might have an issue... lol
Nowadays I'm not so sure. 5-10 years ago, definitely. But it seems like anything you do discipline wise to your kids is wrong now.
My parents and their generation got spanked like it was going out of style ( i guess it was lol), and they turned out fine.
Same here. Personally, I was rarely spanked as a kid. But I was really shy, and a HUGE crybaby, lol.
I don't mind spanking as long as it's used sparingly and done with the bare hand, not a belt (which, btw is child abuse under CA law). I can count on one hand the number of times I was ever spanked, and I deserved it each time. But I think it's a load of BS that spanking itself leads to a lower IQ - they need to look more at who is doing the spanking.
in anger.
Something my husband and I strive for is to parent in love, not in anger. We haven't spanked, but we would if the situation was serious and nothing else would get through to them. We both have an agreement if one of us is emotional or angry, we let the other handle the problem with a clear head.
But for my toddler, time-outs may as well be the apocalypse. She thinks her world has ended when she has to sit on the steps with her hands on her knees!
not a belt (which, btw is child abuse under CA law)
I sooo agree with this. I think if your child is threatening their own or someone else's safety, a spanking is in order as a last resort, but to beat your child with a WEAPON is barbaric!!!
I do think that is reaching. Spanking lowers IQs?? Mind you, I rarely spank my children. Time outs work awesome in my house, thank goodness. I do think some parents do overspank their children. But again that is just my opinion
Time outs work awesome in my house, thank goodness
Yep, I don't think it would work to spank my kiddo. Since she was a peanut, my mom has patted her butt and said "Nana's gonna beat you!" and we do it when she is being a rascal. I think she would look at us like we were nuts, bc she is used to "getting her butt beat" as a joke. She does it to me and laughs!
mine gets time out...or we "barder"...i know some people are against that but it works for my child...she has gotten a spaking on the butt a few times...but each time she is sat down...told why she is getting it and she repeats back to me so i know she understands....and after she gets a swat she sits in my lap and i hug her and we talk about it.....and the same goes with time out...i always make sure SHE understands what she did wrong!!!!....
...but each time she is sat down...told why she is getting it and she repeats back to me so i know she understands....and after she gets a swat she sits in my lap and i hug her and we talk about it.....and the same goes with time out...i always make sure SHE understands what she did wrong!!!!....
That's awesome! We do the same with both kids. I always, always talk to them about why they are in trouble and when they apologize they have to be able to tell me (or whoever they are apologizing to) why they are sorry.
i always make sure SHE understands what she did wrong
same with my children. They are various ages, but I do the same for all of them. Seldom do I swat their behinds but it has been done.
Time outs and loss of priviledges is how we do our discipling.
But more importantly we reward positive behavior daily so the negative stuff isn't usually an issue. My children know if they behave it will not go unseen. I can't stress this type of discipline enough!!!
Kids love to be loved. And they will listen and follow rules more if they know that it makes you happy and you will acknowledge it.