29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Remilitary.com!

PTSD?????

who's talking here?

MrsH 1
Kerry 2
cdub 2
Rude Rudy 2
bexie 1
AuroraBorednZealous 2
BoxTop Hero 1
Jennin29Palms 2
MOVING AGAIN O 1
IEDhunter 1
a3136236uu 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

IEDhunter --- 15 years ago -

what do you think of it or do you think it is a way for Marine's to cop out of stuff..... My friend has been diagnosed with PTSD from his last deployment to Afghanistan. I wanted to know is there anything i can do to help him. 

MOVING AGAIN O --- 15 years ago -

be there if he wants to talk he will if he doesn't don't push it. we see a lot of this where i work its a very touchy subject. there are still a lot of studies being done about this. what people don't see is the stuff we see.(while being deployed)it can sometimes make being about people very hard. just keep an eye out for the depression. good luck 

MrsH --- 15 years ago -

Depends on the situation. PTSD is real for a lot of ppl, especially military members. I couldn't imagine dealing with some of the things these guys have dealt with and seen BUT I also think there are a lot of ppl who use PTSD as an excuse for poor behavior and bad decisions. I also think PTSD is over diagnosed. 

BoxTop Hero --- 15 years ago -

BUT I also think there are a lot of ppl who use PTSD as an excuse for poor behavior and bad decisions
I agree wholeheartedly.

But I also believe that a lot of men and women get mentally f*cked up over there, and we don't believe them because bottom line: we have no idea. (not say i have the slightest idea of what it's like to be over there.)

Mrs. H, I sort of agree with the "over diagnosing" of it, how do you feel about the purple heart? I'm not trying to open a can of worms in anyway. Just curious. 

a3136236uu --- 15 years ago -

I have been down the PTSD path for the last 4-5 years... at first i ignored it, tried to pretend i didn't have it. It got worse over the years for me. I got completely out of control, my wife talked to her doctor and got me a consult to get help. Of course i didn't want the help, but it was more of an intervention. 2 years of treatment now, and i'm back in control of my life and i'm loving it. PTSD is not curable despite what doctors may tell you, but they can teach you how to cope with it and give the control back to yourself. I still fight problems day to day. But now i can control myself. 

a3136236uu --- 15 years ago -

Just get him help... he will be upset, but eventually will be thankful for it!! 

Kerry --- 15 years ago -

also think PTSD is over diagnosed

I agree with this. I personally know a few guys that are fine but they claimed they had it just to get out of stuff. Which i think is a poor excuse as a Marine. 

Kerry --- 15 years ago -

But there are guys that actually do have it, and like someone else said if he wants to talk about it then be there for him if he doesn't don't push it. 

Rude Rudy --- 15 years ago -

I personally know a few guys that are fine but they claimed they had it

Actually, according to the shrinks, all Marines have alittle PTSD just from going thru bootcamp...Go Figure!!!!!! Maybe we need timeout cards like the Army....LOL 

cdub --- 15 years ago -

i dont think ptsd is over diagnosed at all. medical will do anything and everything they can to NOT diagnose ptsd and try passing it off as something else instead. 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

Misdiagnosed is more like it. Dr's are quick to toss out a diagnosis based on symptoms for mental illnesses.

Take a look @ todays youth. A lot of them are diagnosed with ADHD/ADD. Back when I was a kid they said we had a lot of energy & needed to burn it off so we could focus better. 

Rude Rudy --- 15 years ago -

Back when I was a kid they said we had a lot of energy & needed to burn it off so we could focus better.

Didn't they also have the children walk behind the covered wagons back then....LOL 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

My grandparents were sent to Japanese internment camps in CA following their services in WWII for the US as Translators for Intelligence. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

Remember PTSD has different varieties. Not every case is extreme. I had a stillbirth and was diagnosed with PTSD. It was a traumatic experience and I still haven't gotten over it. At the beginning I felt like I couldn't function, well months. I'll never be 100% over it and I do have triggers that can bring back some intense flash backs. Being pregnant right now is difficult at times.
I'm with someone who has been out of the military 6 years and still struggles with PTSD. I didn't know him when it was bad. I can say the VA sucks for treatment. He's used his private insurance for past counseling and it was very expensive. He doesn't have the patients to deal with the VA. I find it really sad how our veterans and active military are treated when it comes to this. A lot of guys are brushed aside. I can't imagine being in combat and these guys/girls go several times. Some are left with visual scars and disabilities that are a daily reminder. I can say treatment was effective for him. Anxiety and sleeping problems are something he will always deal with. But not everyone wants to admit they have a problem. Remember they are trained to be a man, deal with it. Admitting they have a problem is admitting they are weak in their minds.
Sorry for my ramble. PTSD is brought up a lot. It can be a touchy subject I usually just stay out of it! 

bexie --- 15 years ago -

Remember PTSD has different varieties.

True. My husband was diagnosed with PTSD from past trauma as a child.

But not everyone wants to admit they have a problem.

Also True. All this stuff lead to him drinking, which he also did not want to admit that he had a problem there. But he is now getting treatment for it, and he seems to be doing alot better. 

Jennin29Palms --- 15 years ago -

Also True. All this stuff lead to him drinking, which he also did not want to admit that he had a problem there. But he is now getting treatment for it, and he seems to be doing alot better.

Sounds like we have a lot in common free feel to PM me if you ever want to talk 

cdub --- 15 years ago -

Remember PTSD has different varieties. Not every case is extreme.

agreed. ive also been diagnosed with ptsd from experiences in my life.

however, my husband was diagnosed at pendleton with it and when he started seeing ppl out here for it they said he didnt have ptsd he had ADD. which is total bs. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground