I would miss our pictures the most, followed by my son's first baby outfit, and then my little sister's bassinet. We've had that thing for 12 years now and it was used by her, my two cousins, and now my son. I am hoping to pass it on to my little brother someday.
As long as i got my kids and dogs out, nothing else really matters.
There's no way I could grab all the pictures I have all over the house. I'd definitely try to grab our most important papers but all of that can be replaced.
I would miss the blankets, pillow cases such that my Mom has made for my kids... they are VERY special to me! Our pictures, videos of our kids and special family moments! Memories remain even when the materials may be gone.
For this reason I have a folder that has EVERY single important paper we might need. And a few photos, a checkbook, some of the kids art projects, etc. A ton of stuff. It is my "emergency" folder and ready to go if need be. That way in case of an emergency I will not be searching for anything! And that extra second can be used to grab something else. In fact, you guys have inspired me! Tomorrow I am going to finish packing my "earthquake box" with a warm and cold outfit for the children and one of their special toys and stuffed animals.