29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Remilitary.com!

If you...

who's talking here?

cdub 1
IWearHisRank 2
CareBear 16
AuroraBorednZealous 4
peoplesuck 7
kElJoY 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

Wanted to marry someone and your children absolutely hated them and strongly opposed it, would you still do it? Would it depend on how old they were if you did or not anyway? 

peoplesuck --- 15 years ago -

I would not date anyone my children hated so it would not get to that stage in the first place. 

IWearHisRank --- 15 years ago -

would you still do it

I don't think I would marry this person, my kids mean the world to me, and if they were unhappy, then the entire household would be unhappy. IMO 

cdub --- 15 years ago -

no way. 

IWearHisRank --- 15 years ago -

Honestly I believe women/men marry someone ,even when family opposes, when they are selfish! 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

Never. My brother's & I were put in this same situation. My mother was selfish & only thought of her own needs. Everyone thought he was a jerk, so she cut them out of her life too. My brother's & I were mentally/physically abused by him daily. It wasn't until 15yrs later when he was murdered that she tried to right the wrong she had done years ago. It's been 5yrs since he was killed, & we're finally on talking terms again. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

Glad to see that my husband and I aren't the only ones that feel this way.

We found out THROUGH FACEBOOK OF ALL PLACES that my father in law proposed to his girlfriend (who my husband and sister in law can't stand because of how she has mistreated them in the past along with various other reasons). My husband told him how he felt and his dad and soon to be stepmom think he's just being mean and said they don't care how he and his sister feel about it because they don't need anyone's approval. Oh, and they didn't feel the need to call and tell him they were engaged because they figured putting it on facebook first would tell everyone at the same time.

Well, I flat out told him next time we get pregnant they can find out on facebook and that we won't be visiting for a while because I don't want to be around someone that can care less about their children's feelings. I guess that may be taking it too far, but that's how we feel right now. 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

My reply was towards children still in the physical custody of their parents as minors.

As an adult child, protesting the happiness of a parent. It doesn't bother me, cause it's their life.

Hell, I think both my sister-in-laws are gold diggin B's & I've voiced my opinion to my brother's. However I've left it at that. Rather than burn bridges with my brother's I deal with those tramps during those rare times we do get together & see one another. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

As an adult child

It isn't my business.


If something were to happen to my husband, I doubt I would even look at another man until at least my kids were grown - and then it wouldn't be their business who I dated/married. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

I don't care how old my children are, if they disliked someone I wouldn't date them, much less marry them... especially if them not liking them is a result of stuff that happened while they were children and all living together. I think it's selfish. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

I think it's selfish.

What is? 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

Not caring about how your children feel in the name of your own happiness. I mean, it's not like this is just something minor, this will affect the entire family. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

Are you talking about adult children or minors? 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

There are both involved. 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

I'm confused...are you saying there's minor children involved? Is your sister-in-law the minor? 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

It really depends on the situation. Children can dislike someone a parent is dating sometimes just because it takes time away from them - not because anything is particularly wrong with the relationship itself.

As far as being an adult and dealing with it - I stand by - it isn't my business if it is my parents nor would it be my children's business if I was dating someone they didn't like and they were adults.

Just like - once my children are adults - it won't be my business who they choose to date/marry. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

Well, I flat out told him next time we get pregnant they can find out on facebook and that we won't be visiting for a while because I don't want to be around someone that can care less about their children's feelings. I guess that may be taking it too far, but that's how we feel right now.


I'm curious about this part - it isn't YOUR parent, right? Why would you involve yourself to that level? I can understand your husband struggling with it maybe but why are you if it isn't your parent? 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

I see where you're coming from Kel, but their reason for not liking her is not because of that reason. She has been emotionally abusive to them since she moved in with their father (but never to her children, of course). She still is sometimes to this day- I witnessed it while we were home on e-leave.

I guess in my family adult or not, children's feelings are still taken into consideration especially when you're close nit like we are. Marriage isn't something that just affects the couple, it affects everyone. 

peoplesuck --- 15 years ago -

I agree if the children are in fact adults then that parent has a right to be happy and if the adult children can't be happy for them then they are the ones being selfish, ESP if they do not live with the parent. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

why are you if it isn't your parent? 

I'm not- I got a nasty facebook message from my father in law because my husband's phone was off and my husband told me to tell him that. Sorry, I should have been more specific... a lot of the confrontation happened through them messaging my husband and I after my husband talked to them on the phone.

Either way, based on how this woman treats my husband and sister in law, I don't want her around my child or him calling her grandma. Why would I? 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

I agree if the children are in fact adults then that parent has a right to be happy and if the adult children can't be happy for them then they are the ones being selfish, ESP if they do not live with the parent. 

Would you honestly be happy for your father if he was marrying someone that had been emotionally abusive to you for 10 years? 

peoplesuck --- 15 years ago -

No but it wouldn't be my choice. If she had been abusive for ten years I wouldn't come around at all so it wouldn't matter to me at that point. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

If she had been abusive for ten years I wouldn't come around at all so it wouldn't matter to me at that point.

Exactly. Same here.

They say you can pick and choose your friends but not your family - uh, yeah you can. As an adult of course; not as a child. 

peoplesuck --- 15 years ago -

Agree Kelly Jo 

AuroraBorednZealous --- 15 years ago -

Would you honestly be happy for your father if he was marrying someone that had been emotionally abusive to you for 10 years?

Sure, as an adult. I don't live with my parents, so I don't give a crap who makes them happy in their advanced age. It's not like you can't defend yourself as an adult against more emotional abuse. 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

Sounds to me Yule that you need to DEFRIEND the father-in-law lol. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

No but it wouldn't be my choice.

It's not that my husband feels it should be his choice, it's that he's being ridiculed for not being supportive of it.

If she had been abusive for ten years I wouldn't come around at all so it wouldn't matter to me at that point.

I honestly don't even know why he does... those were my thoughts after he told me a long time ago what went on... I would have been gone and not bothered with them anymore. I think he's just really clinging onto his dad because of his mother passing away last year. 

CareBear --- 15 years ago -

Sounds to me Yule that you need to DEFRIEND the father-in-law lol.

Trust me, I did. Maybe now they'll learn to pick up a phone? 

kElJoY --- 15 years ago -

I think he's just really clinging onto his dad because of his mother passing away last year.


That's his deal though - not yours. However, you can choose whether or not you visit or have contact with them for yourself and your child. If your husband wants to visit or have contact - that's on him. I wouldn't take that on. But I would let him deal with it and just be there for him. 

peoplesuck --- 15 years ago -

Well he has two choices. Either deal with it and be supportive regardless of how he feels because it isn't going to change or he can choose to not be in his fathers life. He has to choose one or the other. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground