So just got off the phone with my girl, she and her husband were on their way home from Vegas (sober!) out by the salt mines (middle of nowhere) at around 4 AM, when they see a car flip off the road and roll about 3 times. They stopped and called 911, there was a Marine in the car driving back from Wisconsin on leave who was miraculously alive and conscious and managed to get himself out of the car. The windshield was touching the steering wheel. They let him sit and wait in their car for heat and gave him some water and try to keep him awake in case he had a concussion until CHP could get there. When did CHP show up? 9AM!!!! Almost 5 HOURS LATER. Keep in mind when she called 911 they hadn't seen him get out yet, had no idea how many ppl in the car, if there were kids, if ppl were badly injured, no clue about any of that yet. To me this is absolutely sickening, if I was that guy or his family I would be calling every media outlet in SoCal. I get that cops and first responders are busy, esp on new year's, but it was 4AM, most of the craziness shoulda been done by then, seems like there's always enough cops around to have checkpoints or hem you up for doin' 40 in a 35 but they were gonna leave this Marine layin' in the desert for 5 HOURS??? This isn't the first instance of this kind of thing out there either. Coz DUI's and tickets bring in MONEY, and helping ppl DOESN'T. This is disgusting. Sorry for the rant, just wanted to share and see if anybody has similar stories or any opinions...
Is the guy ok? Lucky him your friends drove by. That is horrible and yes something should be done about it. There is no excuse for 5 hours. He should raise some h3ll about that even if he is ok. What is he wasnt?
I get that cops and first responders are busy, esp on new year's, but it was 4AM, most of the craziness shoulda been done by then
It was New Years Eve, the CHP is on call 24/7 and they don't always have guys in the area where this happened. My husband and I were coming home from Vegas one night and we were following a Drunk Driver who was driving off the road and going about 100mph. We called the CHP dispatcher and told her our location and she did not even know where it was.Thats the dispatcher, not the cop...And mind you it is in the middle of the desert and the CHP works on the California Highways.The Sheriff would have been a better person to call....Don't come on here making the CHP look bad when you don't know what the reasoning of them being late was.
Wow, My husband and I witnessed an accident years ago. Unfortunately that man didn't survive however lesson for those in the future ask for lifelite if the person involved is seriously injured. They are required to provide helicopter transportation to the nearest hospital trauma center. Hope he's ok and got the attention he needed for his injuries.
The Sheriff would have been a better person to call....
and yes the sheriff might have been the better person to call. Always know your local emergency numbers...
Don't come on here making the CHP look bad when you don't know what the reasoning of them being late was.
Screw that....people who get that job know their area, it's required! Accidents especially one of this nature would be first priority. Had this guy had a wife and baby with him would you still be so heartless?! Show some compassion, there is no excuse for someone to take 5 hours to respond to a scene of an accident. Holiday or not!!!
That is bizarre, I know my son is part of the Fire Explorers here in 29 Palms and rides out quite often with both Station 1 and Station 2. They normally run Code 3 to traffic accidents at the moment they get the call from dispatch in San Bernardino. If they had received a call, it certainly would not have been any longer than 20-30 minutes out there. It could have been an issue of mapping too, finding the location as reported from dispatch. Now, out that far, it probably would have been dispatched to the Wonder Valley station which is a volunteer station, so they may have been pretty busy, or understaffed for New Years Eve. Also the CHP dispatches out of Barstow for the entire desert area, I found that out once when I had to use my OnStar to call for help, and it was going to take 30+ minutes for CHP to respond, so I asked for the Sheriff instead. This does need to be looked into to see what all went wrong on this one for sure, somewhere along the whole chain of events, the ball was dropped apparently.
Also the CHP dispatches out of Barstow for the entire desert area, I found that out once when I had to use my OnStar to call for help, and it was going to take 30+ minutes for CHP to respond, so I asked for the Sheriff instead.
Thank You Mari =]
I've lived in the desert my whole life (except while in college), and I know these dark desert roads scare the heck out of me at night, I won't drive them after dark ever...I can't imagine being in an accident and laying there in the dark waiting for help! I totally support my sons interest in Fire Fighting and Emergency Responding, in the hopes that he can bring much needed relief to those in need one day.
I totally support my sons interest in Fire Fighting and Emergency Responding, in the hopes that he can bring much needed relief to those in need one day.
Very awesome that he's chosen a path to help others. May MANY blessings come his way and he's safe driving those roads to those people in need of help.
Coz DUI's and tickets bring in MONEY, and helping ppl DOESN'T.
Are you serious? I realize that this situation is unfortunate, but do you realize how hard these men and women work on a daily basis? You speak of "Your" tax dollars being spent, but guess what they pay taxes too so essentially they to are paying into their own paycheck. I know quiet a few people that work for the Fire Department, Sheriff's Department, CHP, MBA, and Hi Desert Medical Center and to say that they care more about bringing in money than helping others is ridiculous. Then again it's instances like this where people find fault with the system and get fired up enough to rant and say they do nothing. Nevermind every other day where they're helping people and saving other people's lives...
The gentlemen involved in the accident has a right to be upset I'm definitely not arguing that point, but how do you know they weren't searching for him in the dark?? It does happen from time to time especially in that area or maybe they did have another pressing call. Until all facts are present who can really say what happened. I definitely don't think they ignored the call for help because they were doing traffic stops or taking a break.
If for some reason CHP didn't have the means to get to the area within a reasonable time then they should be in contact with the local area sheriff. Not everyone knows the local sheriff's number, but everyone knows 911 and what does everyone preach "if this is an emergency dial 911", not "call your local sheriff"..seriously. CHP is state wide and they don't just stick to the main 62..wake up! If the JT CHP couldn't respond then it is their responsibility to get the next/nearest patrol car to the scene...if it's broken by district then it should be dispatched by radar to the nearest station response team.
I definitely don't think they ignored the call for help because they were doing traffic stops or taking a break.
I agree with this statement, I don't think it was due to being lazy but I definitely think there was something that went wrong with this call.
Are you serious? I realize that this situation is unfortunate, but do you realize how hard these men and women work on a daily basis? You speak of "Your" tax dollars being spent, but guess what they pay taxes too so essentially they to are paying into their own paycheck. I know quiet a few people that work for the Fire Department, Sheriff's Department, CHP, MBA, and Hi Desert Medical Center and to say that they care more about bringing in money than helping others is ridiculous. Then again it's instances like this where people find fault with the system and get fired up enough to rant and say they do nothing. Nevermind every other day where they're helping people and saving other people's lives...
The gentlemen involved in the accident has a right to be upset I'm definitely not arguing that point, but how do you know they weren't searching for him in the dark?? It does happen from time to time especially in that area or maybe they did have another pressing call. Until all facts are present who can really say what happened. I definitely don't think they ignored the call for help because they were doing traffic stops or taking a break.
Very Well Said!
The people who came up on the accident called 911. That is what you do in a emergency. They didnt call CHP. The dispatcher's job is to know who to dispatch to the area. When you call 911 they dont ask do you want sheriff or CHP. So coming on here and saying they were wrong for calling CHP doesnt make sense. Yes obviously someone messed up big time, and whoever it was should be held responsible.
Yes obviously someone messed up big time, and whoever it was should be held responsible.
Very true, since they all "go to work" at the point they're dispatched, I have to believe that something went terribly wrong with the call, either directions, mapping location, urgency, or something, and I too agree that this incident needs to be inquired about, if for no other reason then to make sure it's addressed in training for all responders.
I don't think it was due to being lazy but I definitely think there was something that went wrong with this call.
I agree. I just get fired up when people say that they do nothing and that it's "Their Tax Dollars" paying them it ranks up their with "We own you because we pay you." They are not owned and they pay taxes too ya know.
They keep logs of calls, enroute times, on scene times, etc and I'm sure this will be reviewed to see what went wrong by all and see what can be done to fix it.
They didnt call CHP.
I thought they might have directly called CHP since the thread said them specifically. If the call is transfered to all emergency response teams available then you might as well attack them all. We don't know what happened to the call. When I said call Sheriff I meant it as knowing all your available options. If CHP wasn't there within an hour or so I would have been calling constantly. Even if the guy 'seemed ok'. No way to know if he had internal bleeding. Hope he was ok though. Just saying not to rely on others even those who are police officers just because they can't be everywhere at once.
I definitely don't think they ignored the call for help because they were doing traffic stops or taking a break.
Very well said.
We took a friend to the airport in Vegas to fly home for Christmas. And on the way back to 29 around 11pm there was a red mustang off in the desert out in the Amboy area. (at the tracks and store) I begged my hubby not to stop, but he did anyways. It was 2 young Marine wives and a newborn. They had hit a curve at the tracks, took out the RR sign, blew out the tires and ended up out in the desert soft sand stuck. They had been waiting 3 hrs for help, we waited another 3 hrs with them.
Their husbands finally showed up. As did the tow truck. But never did any medical help arrive or any type of law officials. I'm not downing anyone but we even called 911 and gave very specific details and directions. We also have a GPS tracking device for such things. So I donNt understand what their excuse could be.
B, did they ask if everyone was out of the car and if anyone was injured? If, they did and they were told "yes everyones out of the vehicle and no, no ones injured", they would have canceled all medical help from the call, now why law enforcement didn't show up is crazy, who called the tow truck? The ladies themselves?
m not downing anyone but we even called 911 and gave very specific details and directions. We also have a GPS tracking device for such things. So I donNt understand what their excuse could be.
I also have many experiences which I don't which to explore on a public message board in which simaler things have happened. When it takes over forty minutes to arrive at the scene of a frantic persons 911 call; something is wrong. (Especially when its in the middle of the night.)
Noone should of had to wait more than forty minutes for this call *and only that long because it is SO far out* screw that; this was a blatant HUGE mistake and everyone at fault needs to pay regardless of if this man is ok. Noone would be so kind if someones one year had flipped over in that car too and had its fricken head smashed in; and then waited five hours for help!!!!
Ok to clarify and respond...
1. I never said they "ignored" the call b/c were taking break, doing a traffic stop, etc...
2. It was right off the highway and my friends stayed there on the side of hwy with blinkers on so there shouldn't have been an issue finding it
3. As 0317wifey said, they called 911, not CHP or a specific agency. It is the dispatcher's job to send the nearest available responder. CHP is who wound up showing up, and yes, Mari, they did come from Barstow.
4. The dispatcher had her number, and nobody ever called back during the 5 hour period for an update, clarifcation on location, any of that.
5. When discussing where police officers spend their time, i.e. writng tickets vs. responding to an accident, I did not mean to imply the individual officer is lazy or has ulterior motives. If there is indeed a problem there, it would be much higher level than the individual patrolling officers. They are doing what they are DIRECTED to do.
6. As far as we know the guy is OK.
Bottom Line Up Front -- There was a potentially life-threatening emergency with unknown number of victims or extent of injuries, and somewhere in the communication chain between the 911 dispatcher and the responding officer, somebody thought it was OK for it to go 5 hours without so much as even a call back to the caller to see if there were any updates or need to increase the priority level of the call (i.e. airlift, etc) and IT'S NOT THE FIRST TIME for that area. It's not THAT far out from town...
Let's be honest, if this had been a family member of any of ours we would be livid. Just because we live/drive in the desert and not the city shouldn't preclude us from a reasonable expectation of safety and protection. They were on a STATE highway...
Sorry Mari I was using my phone and its a pain to post with it.
They did ask those questions they were told by us... we didn't see anyone outside of the car, all parties were still inside the vehicle, 2 females and one baby. The baby was screaming it's head off crying. It was cold and the car was not running any longer for warmth. We could not determine if the baby or anyone had any internal injuries but there were no visible external wounds.
The husbands are the ones who called the tow truck.
Well, the logs are probably public information, so if someone wanted to see the timeline for the responders as PC said earlier, so I'm sure the gentleman should be able to find out where the ball was dropped.
No problem Buttercup, I totally understand having your hands full. I wonder if the ladies in their initial call told them they were all fine but just waiting in the car...and dispatch canceled everyone? I have a sneaky suspicion something happened in the dispatch.