29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Remilitary.com!

INTERESTING CASE

who's talking here?

KelJoY II 11
The Paparazzi 1
Shoes 7
RaeRie 1
DotComMyLife 2
JaysUma 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

because of a firefighter's death. 

The Paparazzi --- 16 years ago -

thats sad..... she is a woman now, thats all that should matter 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

When he died...he was married...I am assuming his will left everything to HIS WIFE...end of story...

If his family had an issue with her gender..well to bad...Its not like she murdered him to claim the funds...SHE is his widow...not the mom 

RaeRie (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

It's disgusting that the firefighter's mom is doing that to her son's wife. Good grief. I agree with theshoefits. It's not like the widow killed him for the money. He died in the line of duty. Why wouldn't she be entitled to those benefits? 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

I think it has to do with this part that instigated the lawsuit:

The attorney for the mother of Thomas Araguz III said Thursday that the firefighter only learned of his wife's gender history and after he found out, he moved out of their home and planned to end the marriage.

In essence, if the mother is correct, her son married this person under fraudulent terms; that's what I gather from a non-emotional view on it. 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

the firefighter only learned of his wife's gender history and after he found out, he moved out of their home and planned to end the marriage.
I am sure at some point then he had planned to update his will...but he never got around to it...soo o well IMO..
I believe the article said they were married for 2 years...so if they are claiming she is not entitled to these benifts are they also going to go and look at everything else she benifted from while married?? 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

Why wouldn't she be entitled to those benefits?

Laws about transgender/gay marriages prohibiting those benefits? I haven't figured that part out. 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

soo o well

lol Shoe! Good point!! 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

her son married this person under fraudulent terms; that's what I gather from a non-emotional view on it.
Its not like she duct taped a vajaja to herself and said hey...marry me!.. it took him 2 years to figure it out...

What is the point of allow DR's to preform a gender change if they cannot then claim to be that sex? isnt that the whole reason she did it? So she would then be a SHE? 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

About the will part - that's interesting you say that Shoe because I know the FIRST thing I did when I got divorced; well actually way before I divorced - when I left - was change my beneficiary on my insurance policies back to my parents - IMMEDIATELY lol. 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

What is the point of allow DR's to preform a gender change if they cannot then claim to be that sex?

They can't implant ovaries and a uterus ...so are they really a man gendered into a female?

Texas doesn't recognize same sex marriage so....consequently, they would not recognize this person as a female by law. 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

I know the FIRST thing I did when I got divorced; well actually way before I divorced - when I left - was change my beneficiary on my insurance policies back to my parents - IMMEDIATELY lol.

EXACTLY!!!!...I mean I can try to be rational and say he may have been in shock when/if he did find out and maybe needed a little seperation time to adj and figure it all out...but if he was dead set on leaving her...he would have updated all that ASAP...and had he contact a divorce attorney at all...that is the first thing they would have told him to do...he was a fire fighter after all...he knew that his will needed to be current and accurate... 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

Some of the comments on the article underneath are mighty.....interesting we'll say. 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

They can't implant ovaries and a uterus ...so are they really a man gendered into a female?
physiologically..yes..in her mind..she is a SHE and a female.

Texas doesn't recognize same sex marriage so....consequently, they would not recognize this person as a female by law.
When you get married you have to provide proof of who u are...either brith certificate, DL, military ID...SOMETHING...
So somewhere she was issued a a form of ID that stated she was a FEMALE:/


I LOVE reading the comments left on the YAHOO articles! lol 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

They can't implant ovaries and a uterus ...so are they really a man gendered into a female?
physiologically..yes..in her mind..she is a SHE and a female.


Not according to:

a 1999 appeals court ruling that stated chromosomes, not genitals, determine gender.

It reminds me of the constant debate about at what point does a baby become a baby in uterus...some things just are. 

JaysUma --- 16 years ago -

I watched this on the news the other night and they said that by law ur supposed to release that info or its a fraudjulent(sp) marriage. Just like if ur aware u have aids and don't inform ur partner before marriage its illegal( or so I was told) dnt hold me to it. But anyways that's what they said on the news. 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

I watched this on the news the other night and they said that by law ur supposed to release that info or its a fraudjulent(sp) marriage.

Does the law state HOW you are to release the info? Who says she JUST now told him? Where is that proof?

[i]It reminds me of the constant debate about at what point does a baby become a baby in uterus...some things just are. [/i]
So you have the choice to acknowledge you forgot your condom and are now having a baby...or the choice to say no..its not a baby yet..take whatever is growing in me and dispose of it please (nothing grows that is not living)
and you have the choice to have a gender change...but not the choice to have it acknowledged? 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

I guess therein lays the question for this case.

I think it will be an interesting case to watch. 

DotComMyLife --- 16 years ago -

(nothing grows that is not living)

What about a tumor? Should that not be removed at all because it is living? I ask this from pure curiosity, not trying to be ugly or anything. What is your take on that? (I personally do not believe in abortion unless there are extreme cercumstances involved. i.e. rape, etc.) 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

A tumor isn't a living human being; that being the difference. 

Shoes --- 16 years ago -

What about a tumor? Should that not be removed at all because it is living?

A tumor isn't a living human being; that being the difference.

very well said! :)

I think it will be intersting to watch as well :) 

DotComMyLife --- 16 years ago -

I was just asking because of the way it was worded by shoe. These college courses are making me over analyze everything nowadays. 

KelJoY II --- 16 years ago -

These college courses are making me over analyze everything nowadays.

Nothing wrong with thinking. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground