29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Housebreaking Puppies

who's talking here?

Kerry 1
Megan B. 2
Hammer's Wife 2
jerks 5
((Melissa)) 1
Elizabeth24 1
SouthernSweetheart 10
*Mrs.Sarah* 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Hammer's Wife --- 17 years ago -

I need help. We have three dogs. Our puppy, 4 1/2 months refuses to be housebroken. We take her out about every hour and she does pretty good. I also tell her "good girl" and give her positive reinforcement. When we take her out we always tell her "go potty" and she pretty much does on command, but she refuses to let us know she needs to go. We even put bells on the front and jingle them whenever she goes out. We have tried the potty pads and they work all right, but sometimes she refuses to use them. Is it mean to put her nose into it when she potty's on the floor and then tell her no and put her outside. She is getting huge now and the mess is getting bigger. She is now 45lbs. When we got her at 8 weeks, she was only 13lbs. 

Kerry --- 17 years ago -

i don't think its wrong to put her nose in it. That is how i use to train my dogs if they went and the house!!! Some other people might disagree with you on this but i think you are doing everything right 

((Melissa)) --- 17 years ago -

thats what my hubs did to our dog.. now he is to scared to go in the house heheh.. 

Elizabeth24 --- 17 years ago -

I don't think there's anything wrong with taking the pup over to the mess, rubbing their nose in it, smacking them on the butt, telling them no, and then taking them outside to show them where to go to the bathroom. As long as you aren't overly aggressive about it, there's nothing wrong with it, imo. You might try talking to Megan the dog trainer on here. She may be able to help and give you some advice. 

jerks --- 17 years ago -

Do not rub the dogs nose in it. You have to catch the dog in the act of going in the house and yell a strong loud NO and take her outside. If you don't catch them in the act they don't really grasp that it's bad to physically go in the house. They understand that the mess shouldn't be there but not the act of doing it. I house trained my dog in less than 2 weeks with the catch in act NO method 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

i have a chihuhua, she almost always uses her puppy pads.. but if she doesnt.. she uses it in two particular spots.. we always put her nose in it, but not unless it hasnt been there more than a few minutes...and then we go sit her on her puppy pad.. and hold her onto it for a second.. if we dont she immedietly runs away from it.. lol we never seem to catch her doing it.. though.. and if we do, we always get her then. my dog never goes outside, so puppy pads are all she has ever used.. it seems like you are doing everything right to me though.. your dog is already at the age where maybe shes used to doing things the same way, and she is just stubborn and doesnt want to change.. my dog is also less than a year old.. :/ dern house dogs! 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

We used the crate training method for our weimaraner puppy & he was housebroken very fast. 

Megan B. --- 17 years ago -

Do not rub the dogs nose in it. You have to catch the dog in the act of going in the house and yell a strong loud NO and take her outside. If you don't catch them in the act they don't really grasp that it's bad to physically go in the house. They understand that the mess shouldn't be there but not the act of doing it. I house trained my dog in less than 2 weeks with the catch in act NO method Thats EXACTLY what I was going to say! Good job Jerks! 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

crate training? im not familiar with that one.. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

here michelle It works great heres a link http://www.perfectpaws.com/crt.html 

Megan B. --- 17 years ago -

I always crate Train my dogs! 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

oh okay.. that seems good :) mine is already housebroken for the most part.. im gonna have to let my mom keep her when we leave for oki.. which i am DREADING! i love this dog :( im gonna literally cry.. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

My parents have always done that with our dogs growing up.So when my husband & I bought our puppy I did the training since I was home most of the time. You also need to make sure that the dogs crate is not big enough for them to soil in and still have room to lay otherwise this will make it more difficult to train. They do not like to sleep where they go to the bathroom. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

yeah i know.. my chihuahua has her own room lol.. we have a two bedroom apartment.. and its just us.. so for all that space, i think she does a good job! we only have two puppy pads in her room.. and sometimes keep on in the living room, but not if we have people over. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

I never wanted to try puppy pads only because I couldnt have them laying around the house.lol Our dog would have tore them up Im sure!:] 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

ive never had any trouble with mine tearing them up.. she does really good on them.. when i first started training her.. i put them in the bottom of a liter box.. and put her in it to use the bathroom right after she ate.. she learned that way.. 

jerks --- 17 years ago -

puppy pads This might be more ideal for a small breed dog but I would definately not recommend it for a larger dog and I also feel that at some point all dogs should be using the potty outside. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

Oh I see:] Yeah Im a neat freak & get very anal about different things. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

lol i wish i was a neat freak :/ 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

Yeah thats another thing I wouldnt want my dog to use a puppy pad forever.Not saying anyone does that.Our dog is huge & it would be a gross mess to clean up. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

jerks my dog is a chihuahua lol.. so she is def a small dog.. shes 3.4 pounds, and probably wont get any bigger :] i wish i could get her to go outside more, i walk her everyday .. but she waits until we get back home to use the bathroom. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

Oh gosh my husband tells me to stop cleaning sometimes. clean /neat freak.I use to be really bad about germs but not so much anymore. I would go around spraying lysol on all doors & everything everyday lol. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

lol... thats funny. its good to be like that though. i hate cleaning, but i do it because i dont want a dirty house obviously lol 

jerks --- 17 years ago -

chihuahua's can be really stubborn when it comes to potty training. If the dog is only a few months old it can be corrected with a little time and consistancy but if it has done this for a really long time it could be an almost impossible task. At least her turds will never be the size of softballs. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

lol thats true! she did alot better before we moved here, because our house was hardwood floors, and she had her puppy pad and recognized what it was.. but now we have all carpet, and it took her alot longer to get used to that. 

jerks --- 17 years ago -

I would go around spraying lysol on all doors & everything everyday lol. My husband will not allow me to do this anymore. He sais it is why I always get sick because I don't have an immune system to help fight off germs. He also feels I will kill my kids immune systems by doing this. He never washed his hands much as a child and I swear he never gets sick. 

Hammer's Wife --- 17 years ago -

Thanks for the suggestions. We have caught her in the act too many times to mention and yelled "NO" and put her outside. Not working!!! We have her crate trained and she sleeps in there every night. I do not want to use the crate as a punishment or she will not want to sleep in it. Incidentally, she will pee in her crate too. She doesn't potty in the house right after she eats so that is not an issue. Pooping in the house is not usually an issue either. She only does that once in a great while. Of course my four year old dog will do that too once in a while, usually when I am busy doing something else and am not paying attention to when he wants out. Any other ideas. I am going to try the old rubbing her nose in it. That is what my parents always did and it seemed to work with the dogs when I was growing up. Maybe it will work with my puppy too. 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

rubbing their nose in it has always worked with our dogs, if its fresh poop. if its old, dont bother. 

jerks --- 17 years ago -

The key has to be consistancy as well because if you try to many different things the dog will become confused and you will get a bigger mess than you started out with. 

*Mrs.Sarah* --- 17 years ago -

I would go around spraying lysol on all doors & everything everyday lol. My husband will not allow me to do this anymore. He sais it is why I always get sick because I don't have an immune system to help fight off germs. He also feels I will kill my kids immune systems by doing this. He never washed his hands much as a child and I swear he never gets sick. Yeah I already have a weak immune system from my asthma & all my allergies.I just like knowing Im killing some of the germs.:] 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground