29 Palms Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on 29 Palms bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes in 29 Palms courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Bark collars?

who's talking here?

♥nedo♥ 5
Megan B. 1
Andrea 2
Holly 4
EMilie 1
MamaEm 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

♥nedo♥ --- 17 years ago -

I am trying to find out the best solution to my dogs barking, his bark is so loud and i cant stand the noise. He barks every time people our outside playing or walking their dogs. Also he tends to whine a lot and so i was wondering if bark collars help with the whining also? If any one knows from experience about bark collars please let me know. 

Holly --- 17 years ago -

I thought about doing bark collars on my dogs bu the only ones I ever saw were shock and I would not do that. But what I did when my boys were puppies is everytime they would go outside and bark I would eiter hit them with rolled up newspaper or spray them with water. (My dogs hate getting wet) And eventually they stopped. Now when they go outside to bark I bring them back in for a while. They love to be outside so bringing them in and closing the door is like a punishment. Oh and when I sprayed them with water I didn't use a little spray bottle I grabbed the hose! lol 

♥nedo♥ --- 17 years ago -

see I've never liked hitting my dog as punishment its like spanking a child for being bad, i just cant do it. Now spaying them with water though, that's a perfect idea, my dog hates water, he hates baths so i can only imagine what he would do if i sprayed him with water when he barks or whines. But the shock collars its a good idea but is it really effective? is it pain full? I have a chihuahua terrier mix, so i worry about him being injured. Are those safe for all sizes of pets? 

Holly --- 17 years ago -

What turned me off to a shock collar was a video I saw on youtube. A guy put a shock collar on. Here it is: Shock Collar If it can hurt a human there is no way in hell I would put it on my animal I am all for hitting dogs and I'm not saying your are wrong or not for not doing it yourself. But one thing people dont realize is when you hit them with rolled up newspaper it's not the strike that hurts them, it's the loud popping noise it makes. It makes their ears rings for a while. But again, It's a personal choice. But you should deff. try water. I did it with mine for only a week or 2 when they learned. And I have 2 huge dogs lol 

EMilie --- 17 years ago -

Shock Collars are a very inhumane way of training your dog. Yes they are painful, it's what turns the dog off from barking, but unless you would shock your child every time they were loud, then it is NOT the way to train your dog. 

♥nedo♥ --- 17 years ago -

wow from watching a few of those videos it looks painful. i cant do that to my dog. no way.... when you hit them with rolled up newspaper it's not the strike that hurts them, it's the loud popping noise it makes. If that's the case then I'll give that a shot if the water fails.. What do you do about whining? same thing? 

Andrea --- 17 years ago -

thats because the guy kept turning up the setting level. level 1 didnt look like bad. i was thinking about getting a remote one for gunner. not when he was barking but when he tries to hump my son... 

MamaEm --- 17 years ago -

They make collars now that will spray stuff that irritates the dog instead of shocking him. 

Holly --- 17 years ago -

What do you do about whining? same thing? When it comes to whinning I just let them do it. I try very hard not to let my dogs bark but hey I have to hear everyone elses dogs they can hear mine. The only time my dogs whined was when we would lock them outside and I would just ignore them. Eventually they get over it. Kinda like a baby when it cries. Sometimes if you let it cry it will cry itself to sleep or just get bored of crying an stop. So I would say deal with it. Turn the music or TV up and sooner or later they will see it's not getting them anywhere and stop 

♥nedo♥ --- 17 years ago -

I have been ignoring him but sometimes he never stops. So i tired the whole water thing and my dog just looked at me like i was crazy... i guess im going to have to resort to the other option. If the water fails again. 

Andrea --- 17 years ago -

I have been ignoring him but sometimes he never stops. So i tired the whole water thing and my dog just looked at me like i was crazy... i guess im going to have to resort to the other option. If the water fails again. yea gunner is starting to try to drink the water when i spray him now ... lol. 

Holly --- 17 years ago -

lol. Mine hate water to much to try and bite it lol. I also did this with my dogs: When they start barking taking either Bitter Yuck and spraying that in their mouth. But if you don't want to spend the money on bitter yuck, regular white vinegar works too. Just fll the cap and pour it in their mouth. It's prefectly safe to eat. Even for humans. The only reaosn it vinegar didn't work for me was cause go figure, my dosg like the taste! 

♥nedo♥ --- 17 years ago -

You know i had thought i heard about vinegar working i just couldn't remember. I'll take that with the water. 

Megan B. --- 17 years ago -

Ok shock collars will work if you read the instructions that come with the product! I don't recommend them because I think there are other ways to training! I would suggest getting a water bottle and spray your dog in the legs or butt when it barks.NEVER EVER spray a dog in the face!! It can lead to the dog snapping and that is something you don't want your dog to start doing! And it will really work if your dog doesn't like water! If your dog tries to eat the water cause it likes it then get Bitter Apple or Bitter yuck and add it to the water that way the water taste nasty to them! I would only recommend a shock collar if you have seriously tried EVERYTHING else!! Also I worry about people that strike their dogs because some dogs take that and turn into being aggressive! You just have to watch it. And if you ever strike your dog never in the face. Just like we don't like getting hit in the face they don't either! You never want you dog to start snapping and they might of they keep getting hit in the face!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

29 Palms Underground